Not the Same Trick: the 'Four Magical Chords'

Collier's other famous modulation

Collier's celebrated 'In the Bleak Midwinter' modulation — landing in G half-sharp, a key between the frets — is a different machine and worth keeping separate. There, four rising chords each hold a common tone with the chord before while everything else drifts microtonally sharp, so the ear is towed across a border no equal-tempered instrument can name. The diminished crossroads works in twelve-tone land and lives on your fretboard; the magical chords exploit tuning itself. Same instinct underneath both: keep one thing constant, and you can move everything else as far as you like.

The twelve-tone cousin you CAN play
Source: Ethan Hein's analysis of the arrangement — each chord shares a tone exactly in common with the previous while drifting sharp.
Chold 3
Dnew 1 · was 2
A7new 5⁷ · was 6
Play this on the neck in Key Change Lab →

More Field notes